| Platinum | El Volcan Mexican Grill & Cntn |
| Gold | Hacienda Vieja Mexican Grill |
| Silver | Los Cabos Mexican Grill and Cantina |
| Bronze | Carmen's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Chipotle Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | El Maguey Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Los Compas Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Queen Taco |
| Top Pick | Salty Iguana Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Tequileros Mexican Restaurant |
