| Platinum | Fun House Pizza |
| Gold | Square Pizza |
| Silver | Tim's Pizza |
| Bronze | Fattyhead Keto Dough |
| Top Pick | D'Bronx |
| Top Pick | Flying Horse Flatbreads |
| Top Pick | Minsky's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Pasta & Pizza |
| Top Pick | The 640 Pizza and Pints |
| Top Pick | Toscano's |