| Platinum | Hacienda Vieja Mexican Grill |
| Gold | Catrinas Tacos & Tequilas |
| Silver | Los Compas Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Chipotle Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | La Fuente Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Los Amigos Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Palacio Maya |
| Top Pick | Ranchero's Mexican Food |
| Top Pick | Tequileros Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Lunch Box |